Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Error: boolResponse: signature error: openpgp: unsupported feature: unknown critical signature subpacket type 33 #48

Open
Czino opened this issue Mar 17, 2022 · 0 comments
Labels
help wanted Extra attention is needed

Comments

@Czino
Copy link

Czino commented Mar 17, 2022

I encountered an error on iOS (at least 14.5)

I am trying to verify a signature of following message (IBAN is a fake number I got from here )

{"id":"sepa-IE29AIBK93115212345678","type":"sepa","iban":"IE29 AIBK 9311 5212 3456 78","beneficiary":"Czino"}

Signature is the following

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: openpgp-mobile

wsBzBAABCAAnBQJiM0WyCZDC169C4FaYTRahBMJzmMRBrEtlBEgCgMLXr0LgVphN
AAAlzQf+IK9uvxurJIa6ABf4hQn9Li48+TiERsFq60fTJw+f5kopIHGGwAhr4OKb
GoBaCW/9WU1g22GSphysKgEnPgvjsM/8WfkY0ZfE3UrcaSoj3TlwLfrwCNWcFxfb
tNN1J88Q58U9LRksetnjzzzbKy6O/3Cz0BF7MT2f0YKhT8jCXg1e0/ngMqZOJMJc
PN8GYXFW093ijMZt5G5rMSTTl3JMXA9eHFSK7Nl2kmQIp2M1QKL8EOO8OWQfyRVs
jsocjb/ch1E++LEaNaTybXT56aCd/VSFOyjGukJMvO5KEvGFIhwVRtJN0yeQR527
LEop4jqbAPz98qnLwSw7csLKWS84Kw==
=x8ST
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

And the corresponding public key

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: openpgp-mobile
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=/EpH
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

When verifying the signature in react, following error is thrown:

Error: boolResponse: signature error: openpgp: unsupported feature: unknown critical signature subpacket type 33
To make sure the signature itself is indeed correct, I imported the pubKey to my gpg keychain and verified the signature via gpg --verify which yields a good result

In react, I use the following to sign and verify:
const signature = await OpenPGP.sign(message, publicKey, privateKey, '')

and

await OpenPGP.verify(signature, message, publicKey)

$ gpg --verify message.txt.asc 
gpg: assuming signed data in 'message.txt'
gpg: Signature made Thu 17 Mar 15:29:06 2022 CET
gpg:                using RSA key C27398C441AC4B6504480280C2D7AF42E056984D
gpg: Good signature from "" [unknown]
gpg: WARNING: This key is not certified with a trusted signature!
gpg:          There is no indication that the signature belongs to the owner.
Primary key fingerprint: C273 98C4 41AC 4B65 0448  0280 C2D7 AF42 E056 984D
@jerson jerson added the help wanted Extra attention is needed label Nov 18, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
help wanted Extra attention is needed
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants